Earuy Lire 9 their treatment of the Indians or of each other. Even murder could not be punished, because there was no court before which the offender could be tried. As the trade ex- panded, competition became keener and the methods of the traders more unscrupulous. When two or three traders competed in the same area the furs went to the highest bidder, and the highest bidder was generally he who consented to ply the Indians most thoroughly with liquor. All accounts are agreed as to the terrible effects of liquor on the Indians; as Mackenzie wrote, they were “great sufferers from their communication with the subjects of civilized nations.”” ‘The traders resorted to every means, not stopping short of murder, to secure the furs, persuading the Indians to break their pledges to rival traders and to the Hudson’s Bay Company. Unrestricted com- petition not only debauched the natives, but damaged the trade and extinguished such good opinion as the Indians had of the white strangers. Retribution threatened in an Indian rising in 1780, in which a few white men were killed; but before this had spread a re ee